A good tenancy often starts well before the agreement is signed. When landlords screen prospective tenants carefully and consistently, they are not looking for a ‘perfect’ applicant. They are gathering the right information to make a fair, informed decision, protect their property and give a tenancy the strongest possible start.

For landlords in Swindon and the surrounding area, the practical challenge is balancing speed with care. A property may attract several enquiries quickly, but accepting the first applicant without checks can create avoidable difficulties later. Equally, an overly intrusive or inconsistent process can put good tenants off. The answer is a clear process that is applied fairly to every applicant.

Set your criteria before advertising

The most reliable way to screen prospective tenants is to decide what you need to check before enquiries arrive. This keeps decisions focused on the tenancy rather than first impressions and helps every applicant understand what will be required.

Your criteria should reflect the property and the proposed tenancy. For example, consider the maximum number of occupiers the home can accommodate safely, whether pets may be suitable, the proposed tenancy start date, and whether the applicant’s household income is likely to support the rent and normal living costs.

Affordability is usually central. Many landlords and letting agents use an income assessment, often based on a multiple of the annual rent, but there is no single figure that suits every tenancy. A household with a lower income but a strong guarantor, savings or a stable rent payment record may still be a sound applicant. The point is to use a sensible, documented approach rather than make assumptions.

Be careful that your criteria are lawful and applied equally. Under the Equality Act 2010, applicants must not be treated less favourably because of protected characteristics such as disability, race, religion, sex, age, pregnancy or maternity. Blanket policies can also cause problems. For instance, a general refusal to consider applicants receiving benefits may amount to indirect discrimination in some circumstances.

Start with a useful initial conversation

An enquiry form or first telephone conversation should establish the essentials without becoming an interrogation. Ask who will live at the property, their preferred move-in date, their employment or income position, whether they have pets, and why they are moving.

This stage is also an opportunity to explain the rent, deposit, tenancy length and any property-specific restrictions clearly. A tenant who understands the full cost and practical expectations of the tenancy is less likely to withdraw late in the process.

A viewing can add helpful context, but it should not replace formal checks. Being personable, arriving on time or expressing enthusiasm for a home may be encouraging, yet none of these things confirms that rent will be paid reliably. Treat every viewing as the beginning of a professional conversation, not the final decision point.

Use referencing to verify the key facts

Referencing turns an applicant’s information into evidence. It commonly includes identity verification, an affordability assessment, credit checks where appropriate, employment or income confirmation, and a previous landlord reference.

Employment references can confirm job title, employment status and income, although employers vary in what they are willing to disclose. For self-employed applicants, recent accounts, tax documentation, bank statements or an accountant’s reference may provide a more realistic picture. Retired applicants or those receiving benefits may have equally dependable income, but the evidence required will naturally differ.

A previous landlord reference can be useful when it is specific. Rather than relying on a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’, ask whether rent was paid as agreed, whether the property was cared for, if there were any material breaches of the tenancy, and whether the landlord would let to the tenant again. Remember that a reference is one part of the picture. A tenant may have moved because their former landlord sold the property, needed to move back in or failed to maintain it properly.

Credit information should be considered proportionately. A historic missed payment or low credit score does not automatically mean someone will be a poor tenant. Look for the wider pattern, the age of any issue, whether it has been resolved, and whether the applicant can explain it openly. Serious unresolved debt, a county court judgment or insolvency may require further discussion, a guarantor or a decision not to proceed, depending on the circumstances.

Check the Right to Rent requirements

In England, landlords must carry out Right to Rent checks before the start of a new tenancy, unless an exemption applies. These checks confirm that an adult occupier has the right to rent residential property in England.

The process and acceptable documents can change, so it is sensible to follow the latest government guidance or use an appropriately qualified letting agent. Checks must be completed for all relevant adult occupiers, not selectively based on a person’s name, accent, appearance or nationality. Keep the required records securely and diarise any follow-up check where the applicant has time-limited permission to rent.

Right to Rent is separate from referencing. An applicant can pass one and not the other, which is why both should form part of a properly managed application process.

Consider a guarantor when it genuinely helps

A guarantor can provide reassurance where an applicant does not meet your usual affordability assessment alone, has a limited credit history or is starting their first tenancy. This is common for students, younger renters and some applicants who are newly self-employed.

However, a guarantor is not a substitute for checking whether the tenancy is workable. The guarantor should be referenced in their own right and given a clear explanation of the commitment they are making. Their guarantee should be properly recorded within the tenancy documentation, including whether it covers rent, damage, costs and any renewal or periodic tenancy.

It is also worth considering whether a guarantor is really necessary. Requiring one automatically from particular groups can be unfair and may deter otherwise strong applicants. Use the same assessment principles for everyone, and be prepared to explain the reason for your decision.

Handle deposits, holding deposits and data properly

Once you have identified a preferred applicant, communicate the next steps promptly. Delays leave room for uncertainty and can result in a good applicant finding another home.

A holding deposit may reserve the property while checks are completed, but it must be handled in line with the Tenant Fees Act 2019. There are restrictions on how much can be taken, the information that should be provided, the timeframe for agreement, and the limited circumstances in which it may be retained. If you are unsure, seek professional guidance before taking payment.

Personal documents, bank statements and reference information should be treated with care. Only collect information that is relevant, store it securely, limit access to those who need it, and dispose of it safely when it is no longer required. Tenants are entitled to feel confident that their personal details are being handled responsibly.

Keep a record of decisions

The strongest screening process is one you can explain. Make a brief note of the criteria used, the checks completed and any relevant discussions about affordability, a guarantor or special circumstances. This is helpful if questions arise later and encourages consistency when more than one person is involved in selecting a tenant.

If you decline an applicant, keep the response courteous and factual. You do not need to share private details of another applicant or lengthy commentary on references. A simple message confirming that the property will not be offered to them is usually sufficient, particularly where further disclosure could create data protection concerns.

When professional letting support adds value

Landlords who manage their own properties can carry out these checks, but the administration is substantial. Referencing, compliance, tenancy paperwork, deposit handling and ongoing communication all need to be completed accurately and at the right time.

A local letting agent can bring structure to the process while keeping it personal. At Charles Harding, the focus is on helping landlords understand the applicant’s overall position, complete the appropriate checks and move towards a tenancy with clear expectations on both sides. Local knowledge can also help when setting a realistic rent and attracting applicants suited to the property.

The best tenant screening does not rely on instinct alone, nor does it reduce people to a credit score. It is a fair, consistent process that asks sensible questions, verifies the answers and gives both landlord and tenant the confidence to begin well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Estate Agents Swindon: Your Home Selling Experts - Charles Harding
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.